04 /
The Bali & Lombok Property Dispute
Marina Bay City · Nesara/Gesara Bay City · Hotel K
Press-Reported
$7 Million+ Alleged Lost in Lombok Villa Scheme
The Australian reported that at least 30 Australian investors poured more than AU$7 million between April and October 2025 into a waterfront luxury villa complex known as the Marina Bay City project in West Lombok, linked to a businessman previously banned from managing corporations in Australia. The Courier-Mail separately reported that Indonesian police were investigating claims the same businessman was selling villas on land his company did not own.
Official Corporate Statement
Kinnara Limited's Official Dispute Statement (14 March 2026)
Kinnara Limited — an Asia-based property marketing platform describing itself as operating across 76 portals in 44 countries — issued a formal public statement confirming that Lux Projects Bali and Jamie McIntyre defaulted on a binding Conditional Sale and Purchase Agreement for the first five stages of Marina Bay City Lombok; that client funds were mismanaged; that legal proceedings were active in both the Federal Court of Australia and the Denpasar District Court (Case No. 1536/Pdt.G/2025/PN Dps); and that Kinnara and its subsidiaries have no association with McIntyre or his entities.
The statement further records that PT Marina Bay Group issued a December 2025 statement describing McIntyre's claimed 100% ownership of PT Marina Bay Investments as "incorrect, misleading, and contradicted by official Indonesian corporate records," and that no share transfer had occurred under the disputed agreement. It also confirms the project has been rebranded multiple times — from Marina Bay City to Nesara Bay City and Gesara Bay City — under the current LUX Property Group / LUX Projects Bali branding, while the underlying contracting entity, PT Bali Real Estate Investments, has not changed.
Financial Structure Scrutiny
PT Bali Real Estate Investments: Account Balance Questions
TechBullion reported that Christina Natalia, a former director of PT Bali Real Estate Investments, stated company account balances stood at "only in the thousands of Australian dollars" despite millions of dollars in deposits from villa buyers. Construction at Hotel K and related Bali projects has reportedly been halted for lacking the required Building Construction Approval (PBG).
Contractor Dispute
Balinese Contractor Alleges Unpaid Work Across Multiple Projects
BaliNews.co.id reported that a local Balinese contractor alleged non-payment for design, planning and construction work commissioned by a real estate investment company from around January 2024, describing a pattern of late and partial payments before work was halted in August 2025 due to accumulated unpaid costs. The project reportedly involved 15 villa units and more than 100 local workers.
Source Document
Nesara Bay City & Gesara Bay City: "Vaporware" Allegation
The source document describes Nesara Bay City and Gesara Bay City in South Lombok as "eco-village city" developments marketed on aspirational renderings with a 2031 completion date, and claims local land registry searches show no record of the developer owning the marketed land. This specific land-registry claim could not be independently confirmed and should be treated as unverified pending an original source; it is, however, broadly consistent with Kinnara's official statement above, which independently confirms no legitimate transfer of land, brand or ownership rights had occurred as of March 2026.
CONSISTENT WITH OFFICIAL STATEMENT ABOVE